Council members Allaire, McArthur and Gibb alleged there were deficiencies at the Amherstburg Library during council meetings but none have answered my questions about their statements.

Following the February 14, 2025 presentation to Amherstburg town council by Essex County Library Board Mr. Joe Bachetti, Councillor Donald McArthur said, ‘in terms of the one thing there the redesign of physical spaces to promote flexible, welcoming branches that are accessible and modern, I think there must be some challenges in Amherstburg. We have a beautiful building, but it’s not as modern as accessible I don’t think as it as otherwise might be ideal. 

During the April 14 council meeting, Councillor Molly Allaire said she would like the library to have a new place ‘that’s accessible’ and our library service is small and ‘not as accessible as we want it to be,’ and ‘its challenges are inaccessibility.’ 

During the April 14 council meeting discussion, Gibb said, ‘it’s certainly not, well, I’m not gonna say it’s not accessible; it certainly has challenges with the tall shelves. It’s better if you can spread them out and have shorter shelves.’ 

EMAILS TO COUNCIL MEMBERS:

Allaire: During last night‘s council meeting, you said you would like the library to have a new place ‘that’s accessible’ and our library service is small and ‘not as accessible as we want it to be.’ Would you please explain how this library is not accessible? Is this just your opinion? Or did you obtain an expert opinion? Can you cite an authority for your statement or a basis? And who is we? Are you referring to any standard regarding what you want it to be? Emailed April 15, followed up April 18 and 21.

McArthur: During a council meeting earlier this year you referenced an accessible library. Do you consider the current library inaccessible? If so, in what way? Is this your personal opinion? Or did you obtain an expert opinion? Emailed April 16, followed up April 19 and emailed Following up. Since you spoke about accessibility of the Jack Purdie Park trail at the April 14 meeting, I thought you would’ve welcomed an opportunity to comment on accessibility at the library. If not, people might assume you promote accessibility when it suits April 23.

Gibb: During an Amherstburg Residents’ Forum meeting that you attended, I asked you if the library board noted any deficiencies and you answered, ‘none whatsoever.’ During the April 14 council meeting, you said, ‘it’s certainly not, well, I’m not gonna say it’s not accessible; it certainly has challenges with the tall shelves. It’s better if you can spread them out and have shorter shelves.’ So you do think it’s accessible? Don’t all libraries have ‘tall shelves?’ Have you heard of reachers? Will all the library branches be altered so they have ‘shorter shelves?’ Is this just your opinion or an expert’s opinion? Emailed April 23, followed up May 14.

I’ve also reached out to the library board and submitted an FOI request for documentation from same.