Update: Amherstburg’s CAO Defends Closed-Door Training—And Mayor-Elect Gibb Stays Silent

By: Linda Saxon, The Burg Watch

In my previous post, I shared that Amherstburg’s incoming council has five separate orientation and training dates scheduled—November 24, November 30, December 1, December 3, and December 7—and every single one is being held behind closed doors.

Following that email, I sent a formal reply to Chief Administrative Officer (CAO) Valerie Critchley and copied both the town clerk and Mayor-elect Chris Gibb, who were included on the CAO’s original message.

In my follow-up, I reminded administration that the Ontario Ombudsman’s April 29, 2024 report explicitly suggested Amherstburg formalize the practice of treating training sessions as open public meetings to improve transparency. I also asked two direct questions:

  1. Whether council will pass open-session resolutions disclosing the general nature of the training topics beforehand, as required under the Municipal Act.
  2. Which of the five dates covers mandatory training under the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA) and the Ontario Human Rights Code, and who is delivering the curriculum.

What the CAO’s Reply Actually Revealed

CAO Critchley replied to defend keeping the sessions closed. Her response—sent in red coloured text, despite my explicit request to her in August 2025 not to use coloured text —revealed three major takeaways:

  • A Sudden Legal Pivot: In her first email, the CAO stated the sessions would be closed “in accordance with section 239 (3.1) of the Municipal Act.” Yet when asked about the open-session resolutions required under that rule, she changed her argument. She claimed that because educational sessions do not materially advance council business, they do not meet the legal definition of a “meeting” and require no public resolution at all. She ignored the Ontario Ombudsman’s transparency recommendation completely.
  • Recycling the Outdated 2022 Training Package: Regarding mandatory AODA and Human Rights education, she wrote: “This training is provided separately from the Council orientation dates and via the Town’s training software. I believe you have a copy of the version of that training already in your possession from the last Council orientation.” That confirms our incoming council is still receiving the exact same outdated curriculum from 2022—the one that required a Freedom of Information request to uncover and featured a 30-minute Folk Music Ontario video from July 2014.
  • Ignoring Digital Accessibility Requests: Answering an accessibility watchdog’s email in red text—after being asked in August 2025 not to use coloured text—shows how lightly basic digital accessibility is treated at the top of Town Hall.

Mayor-Elect Gibb’s Silence Speaks Volumes

Just as telling as the CAO’s defence is the complete silence from Mayor-elect Chris Gibb.

Gibb was copied on the entire email exchange. He saw administration’s plan to lock the doors for five training sessions. He saw the reminder about the Ontario Ombudsman’s 2024 transparency advice. And he saw the CAO defend keeping taxpayers out before the new term even begins.

So far, he has said nothing.

During the recent election campaign, Gibb defended traditional municipal processes. By remaining silent while administration shuts the public out of council orientation, our incoming mayor is effectively condoning business as usual before even taking the oath of office.

Transparency Is a Choice

Even if administration argues these orientation sessions fall outside formal meeting rules, keeping the doors locked remains a choice, not a legal requirement. Other Ontario municipalities—like the City of Cambridge—actively welcome residents to observe open portions of council-elect training on governance and community priorities.

Ultimately, staff do not own the council table—elected officials do. Once the new council is sworn in, any member can put forward a motion to open these sessions to the public and formally adopt the Ontario Ombudsman’s April 29, 2024 report recommendation into the town’s Procedure By-law.

The Burg Watch will continue tracking how our newly elected officials handle transparency and accessibility from day one. When lawmakers start their term behind closed doors using decade-old training materials, taxpayers deserve to know.


Closed Doors Before Day One: Amherstburg’s New Council Training Sessions Shut Out the Public

By: Linda Saxon, The Burg Watch

Before our newly elected council even settles into their chairs for the next four years, Town Hall is already locking the doors.

Recently, I emailed Amherstburg’s Chief Administrative Officer (CAO) Valerie Critchley asking to be notified of the upcoming orientation and training sessions for the incoming council. Here is the exact response I received:

“Good Morning:

There will be internal training and education sessions held on November 24 and 30, December 1, 3 and 7. These sessions will not be public meetings in accordance with section 239 (3.1) of the Municipal Act.

Regards,”

Five separate training dates—November 24, November 30, December 1, December 3, and December 7—and every single one of them is being held behind closed doors.

Notably, the CAO copied both the Town Clerk and Mayor-elect Chris Gibb on the reply—meaning our incoming mayor is already aware that these sessions are being closed to the public.

We Have Seen This Exact Playbook Before

This is not the first time administration has put up unnecessary roadblocks around council training.

Following the 2022 municipal election, I asked CAO Critchley when council received accessibility training. She told me it happened on November 29, 2022—yet I could not find accessibility listed on that day’s Council Workshop Agenda. When I asked her to simply email me copies of the training materials provided to council, her response was:

“With respect to your request for documents, please file a Freedom of Information Request.”

I filed that formal FOI request. When I finally received full disclosure, the “secret” training package consisted of just three items:

  • Accessible Customer Service Standard (a public policy already posted on the town’s website)
  • Integrated Accessibility Standards Regulation Policy (another public policy already posted on the town’s website)
  • AODA – Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act 2023 (a slide deck that referenced a 30-minute Folk Music Ontario AODA Customer Service Video from July 2014)

Forcing a resident through an FOI process just to hand over two public town policies and a decade-old music organization video proves that closing these sessions has nothing to do with protecting confidential municipal secrets. It is simply a barrier to transparency—and it raises serious questions about the quality of education our lawmakers are actually receiving.

Legal Does Not Mean Mandatory

Let’s be clear about what the law actually says. Under Section 239(3.1) of Ontario’s Municipal Act, a municipality is permitted to close a meeting to the public for the purpose of educating or training council members, provided no member discusses or advances municipal business or decision-making.

However, closing those doors is a choice, not a legal requirement.

Nothing in the Municipal Act forces a town to hide council orientation from taxpayers. In fact, other Ontario municipalities—such as the City of Cambridge—actively invite residents to observe open portions of their council-elect training on governance and community priorities.

Even more telling is Amherstburg’s own track record. Following a previous closed training session here in town, the Ontario Ombudsman issued a formal report on April 29, 2024, explicitly suggesting that the Town of Amherstburg formalize the practice of treating training sessions as open public meetings to improve transparency.

Two years later, administration is ignoring that recommendation and keeping the doors locked.

The Rules Town Hall Still Has to Follow

Even when a municipality chooses to use the Section 239(3.1) loophole to exclude the public, the law still sets strict boundaries:

  • No Policy or Decision-Making: The Ontario Ombudsman interprets the training exception very narrowly. These five sessions cannot be used to review policy options, debate upcoming town files, or lay the groundwork for future council votes.
  • Mandatory Public Notice: Unlike the missing agenda item in November 2022, council is legally required to pass a resolution in an open public meeting beforehand stating the fact of the closed session and the general nature of the subject matter being covered.
  • Mandatory Accessibility Training: Under provincial law, newly elected officials must receive training on the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA) and human rights obligations. Taxpayers have a right to know how our new council is being educated—especially in a town where the outgoing mayor openly admitted we are not compliant.

What The Burg Watch Will Be Tracking

Transparency is not something politicians should only talk about during an election campaign. It starts with letting residents see how their elected officials are being trained to govern.

I have already sent a follow-up email to the CAO—with the Town Clerk and Mayor-elect Gibb copied or informed—reminding administration of the Ontario Ombudsman’s 2024 transparency recommendation and asking which of these five dates covers mandatory AODA training and who is delivering the curriculum.

The Burg Watch will also be checking the upcoming council agendas to ensure formal public resolutions are passed disclosing the general topics for all five dates. The new term hasn’t even officially started, and the habit of operating behind closed doors is already back in full swing.


Thank Me, Blame Council!

I had been emailing council members since February and urging them to update the procedural by-law and at no point did anyone mention that a review was underway. In September I asked on what date did members of council give direction to admin to update the by-law?

CAO Critchley answered – August 14, 2023.

Technically, that was the day council rubber-stamped the by-law so neither council nor the public had any input, unlike other municipalities. As an example, Port Hope where ‘staff will work with all members of Council to gather their individual input on meeting processes and specific elements of the procedural by-law to ensure the recommended draft by-law is reflective of all points of view on Council.’

When I requested an explanation for missing speaking notes from two October 10 delegates, Critchley answered that ‘Both delegates have indicated that they did not have additional materials to provide and both met the requirements of section 9.4 of the Town’s Procedural By-law. While we certainly welcome delegates to share additional information that they may have in advance, if the requirements of the procedural by-law have been met then the Clerk is required to register the delegation.

It wasn’t just my concern. I shared the Centre For Free Expression’s response with council:

I have never heard of a municipality requiring the delegation speaker’s notes, much less the text of the speech, to be submitted ahead of the event. And, I have never heard of a requirement for a copy of the notes or speech text to be submitted with the application to appear. Sometimes when I appear before parliamentary bodies they request a copy of my submission ahead of time so they can distribute it to the committee members and, where there is simultaneous translation, to give a copy to the translators so as to help them. But, this is only after I have been accepted as a speaker and it is not a requirement.
While I feel it is both wrong and bad practice for your municipal council to do as yours is doing, it is not illegal to the best of my knowledge. It is something that should be fought in the court of public opinion.

ames L. TurkDirector, Centre for Free Expression
The Creative School
Toronto Metropolitan University (formerly Ryerson University)

It also wasn’t my only concern. On several occasions I shared my concerns regarding accommodations for persons with disabilities who were unable to be attend meetings and I mentioned comparator municipalities. Ironically, council has considered comparators for staff wages, budgets, and recommending removing the cheque registry from the agenda. Two more inconsistencies.

My comparator chart was attached to the agenda.

Copyright – this information is protected by Canada’s Copyright Act. Request written permission from the burg watch at gmail dot com.

Lack Of Audio = Lack Of Transparency

I asked CAO Critchley for an explanation for the August 10 Amherstburg Heritage Committee meeting audio starting at 45:40. Just to be sure it wasn’t my computer, other residents verified the same.

This morning Critchley answered, “A technical issue prevented the capture of audio for the first portion of this meeting but was able to be resolved later in the meeting.

The Ontario Ombudsman Open Meetings Guide for Municipalities states:

What are the objectives of the open meeting rules?

The open meeting requirements set out in section 239 of the Municipal Act, 2001 permit the public to observe municipal government in progress. The Supreme Court of Canada answered this question in its decision in the 2007 case, London (City) v. RSJ Holdings Inc. The judges noted “the public’s demand for more accountable municipal government” and stated that open meetings are essential to “robust democratic legitimacy” of local administrations. They also observed that s. 239 of the Municipal Act, 2001 “was intended to increase public confidence in the integrity of local government by ensuring the open and transparent exercise of municipal power.” (original emphasis).

Also from the Guide:

“The democratic legitimacy of municipal decisions does not spring solely from periodic elections, but also from a decision-making process that is transparent, accessible to the public, and mandated by law.”

– Hon. Madam Justice Louise Charron, Supreme Court of Canada